Friday, December 9, 2011

The Condemned Lafayette Cemetery

As you’ll recall from last week’s blog, Bloody Cemetery Apparition, one of the 47,000 displaced souls from on old condemned South Philly cemetery decided to hang out with my son and I for a spell. The fact that Chris saw it too made me feel a bit more sane.

As I commenced to dig into the history of Lafayette Cemetery (which was across the street from the famous Pat’s and Geno’s cheesesteak restaurants until 1947), the situation that presented itself appeared quite gruesome. But let me first take you back a couple years for a key part of the puzzle.

My friend Ken lives in Bensalem, PA, on the outskirts of northeast Philadelphia. As he is well aware of my obsession with cemeteries, he often tells me about interesting graveyards he’s seen in his travels. Near Bensalem is the Neshaminy Mall. Across Neshaminy Boulevard from the mall is a field of grass with a small monument in it. Ken stopped to look at it a couple years ago and told me he thought it was there because graves had been found in the field during some excavation.

Fast-forward to 2011 as I’m researching the history of Lafayette Cemetery. Turns out that the site across from the Macy’s side of the mall is where many of the bodies from Lafayette were buried. Happens all the time (or at least it used to) − a cemetery gets relocated, unidentified or unclaimed remains get reburied in a mass grave. Ah, but it turns out that such was not exactly the case here – by finding the site, we only set aside the first vial of the mystery.

Field monument across from Neshaminy Mall
While a good portion of the 47,000 bodies from Lafayette were buried here, they weren’t buried in the most dignified fashion. Consider this excerpt from the October 9, 1988 edition of the Philadelphia Inquirer:

"Thomas A. Morris, president of Evergreen Memorial Park in Bensalem Township, was contracted to dig up 47,000 sets of remains from the run-down Lafayette Cemetery in South Philadelphia.
Under the terms of a 1946 Common Pleas Court decree, the bodies were to be buried again on 40 of the 156 acres owned by Evergreen, complete with caskets, drainage, new bronze markers, roadways and perpetual maintenance of the grounds. In return, Morris received clear title to the old cemetery property, bounded by Passyunk Avenue and Ninth, 10th, Federal and Wharton Streets."

Not only did Morris not bury the remains in the agreed upon fashion, but he soon sold the South Philly land to investors for $105,000 - who then sold it back to the city for $153,500! This may not seem like a lot of money now, but in 1947, $100,000 had the buying power of just over a million dollars (by 2011 standards).

Unscrupulous financial wheeling and dealing aside, the travesty here is that most of the 47,000 graves were not reburied as they were supposed to be. No tombstones were erected with the graves. What did he do with the old tombstones? We now know that Morris dumped most of the bodies in unmarked trenches on the outskirts of his Evergreen Cemetery property (in Bensalem , PA), as well as some in Bensalem’s Poquessing Creek (according to eyewitnesses!!).

The only reason the public is aware of any of this is because of an accidental unearthing of some wooden coffins on the old Evergreen site in 1988. A strip mall was being built, and the graves were discovered during its construction. Investigations turned up the following:

"After spending a week and a half digging test shafts at the site, officials last week said they had uncovered what probably are 32 trenches, each 300 feet long. Inside the trenches are stacks of wooden boxes, presumably containing most of the remains." (ref)

Are they really resting in peace?
The marker was only placed at the site in 1988 after the mass grave was accidentally discovered. Two bronze plaques flank it, dedicated to Civil War veterans known to have been buried at Lafayette. After Morris’ onerous actions became apparent, investigations continued into his other deal with the city for moving Franklin Cemetery in Philadelphia’s Kensington neighborhood. In 1948, Morris was paid another $100,000 to move 8,000 bodies. Of that number, about 5,000 are unaccounted for!

Now realize that in the 1940s and 1950s, the vast majority of people thought stodgy old graveyards were an eyesore and should be eradicated. Victorian architecture, ironwork, and stone carvings were thought to be gauche. Given a cemetery that was a hundred years old where the few descendants that cared (and had the money) had already moved their loved ones out, the public really wasn’t concerned about where the bodies went. I can’t help but wonder now how the owners of those expensive suburban homes near the Neshaminy Mall felt after learning that there were thousands of mouldering corpses in their backyards.

But that’s probably no weirder than human remains under the Capitolo Playground. I mean think about it – there must be some there. When you look at the size of the Bensalem land in question, its hard to believe 47,000 bodies could be buried there − even if the hole was REALLY deep. My guess is that many of the original graves still reside under the Capitolo Playground in South Philly. The City of Philadelphia pays this guy $105,000 to dig up the bodies and rebury them elsewhere, but doesn't check to make sure he actually DID that properly. Then the city buys it back (for $54,000!) to build a playground. He knows they’re just going to pave some areas and plant grass in others – so he has no incentive to fully excavate the grounds and remove every grave!

"In 1951, the Securities and Exchange Commission began to look into Morris' dealings - particularly his apparent habit of selling large blocks of Evergreen Cemetery lots to speculators with the promise that the investors would be able to sell them for huge profits. The sales, according to the SEC, were in the same category as sales of securities, and Morris was not registered to sell securities.

Morris began to pile up debts, with the federal government filing tax liens against Evergreen Memorial Park. In 1958, the Pennsylvania Securities Commission asked that the courts appoint a receiver for Evergreen. In 1959, Evergreen filed for bankruptcy." (ref)

Capitolo Playground
The new owners renamed Evergreen Cemetery Rosedale Memorial Park, which exists on the site to this day. It is a well-maintained active cemetery. I guess after finding all this out I’m surprised that we don’t have MORE ghostly sightings in the area of the Capitolo Playground given the vast amount of graveyard residents who were so vilely disturbed from their final resting places. I think about the guy in the bloody suit who sat down with me and my son Chris, about WHERE his body may have ended up. Maybe he's still searching for it. And where ARE all those thousands of other bodies …?

(The Philadelphia Inquirer, October 9, 1988)

Bloody Cemetery Apparition  (Last week's Cemetery Traveler blog posting)

Bensalem, Roots Web


  1. My ancestors were among those buried in the Fayette Cemetery in Philadelphia. Thank you for continuing the interest in their final (?) resting place....


  2. My ancestors were among the lucky ones whose family chose to move their remains themselves. They are now buried in Lakeview Memorial Park in Cinnaminson NJ. Are there cemetery records for Lafayette somewhere? I have been trying to find some records for my family for a couple of years.

    1. I would think that the records are available at the Penna. Historical Society, in Philadelphia. Most records of defunct cemeteries are.

    2. The PHS has them on microfilm. I have used many of them for research but I don't remember if I have used Lafayette or not.

    3. Films of the Lafayette cemetery records are held by the Family History library of the Mormon Church. They used to be available for rent at any FHLC facility. You'd have to contact a local branch to see if that's still the case. PHS does have them in their library.

  3. I have relatives that were buried in Franklin. After reading this, I wonder now if they were actually moved or are they among the unaccounted for? What a shame!

  4. My Family's graves were moved from the Odd fellows at 26th and diamond in Phila to the LawnView back in the early 50's. Now I am wondering if they to were just cased just anywhere.
    At the time my Grandmother was a single mother and did not have the money to move them as it was passed down. In the early 1990's looking into my family history is when I discovered that this happened, at that time I did place a plaque on what they told me was their grave. Twelve body's in one grave.This all has me thinking now.

  5. I have just found the original payment book for a plot(4 spaces) in Evergreen Cemetary that my grandfather paid $250 in 1946. Interestingly the plot is in the "Lafayette Section." So it is obvious that Morris not only did not bury the Layfayette remains in the section but he boldly sold the lots in that section to others.

  6. I have a record of three (3) remains transferred from Lafayett Cemetery in 1946 and buried in Holy Cross Cemetery (Yeadon, PA). Craddock, Kennedy and Smith.

  7. I have ancestors that were buried in the Lafayett Cemetery. Something I just found out. Thank you for sharing this!

  8. This would explain why I can't find my G G G Grandmothers grave site! This totally sickens me!!

  9. Google "Thomas A. and Minerva Morris" and page down -- you will find a photograph of the man I believe is the infamous Mr. Morris. Courtesy of a Philadelphia area genealogist whose ggg grandmother once rested in Lafayette Cemetery.

  10. There was a little baby in my husband's family buried in Franklin in 1862. Probably some more family, too, but at the very least her. Bet she did not get moved.

  11. Just curious. Where is Thomas A. Morris, president of Evergreen Memorial Park buried?

  12. Mary Kennedy, Thomas Chaddock, Katherine Walsh & Herbert Smith were buried in Lafayette Cemetery. Their remains were removed by my family and buried in Holy Cross Cemetery, Yeadon, PA in December 1946

  13. Four of my ggg grandparents children were buried in Franklin Cemetery. I wonder where they ended up.

  14. I hope news of his greed came out before he passed away, so he died with people knowing of his criminal activity. According to the Philadelphia death certificates index, my great-great-grandfather George W. Kelly and his second wife, Sarah, had 4 babies that were buried at Lafayette Cemetery. At the time the parents were residing at 91 Moore Street, Ward 1. Meriam C Kelly, 24 June 1888, 10 months. Walter Kelly, 15 May 1890, 18 months. William Kelly and John Kelly, 2 June 1890, 1 day. The family also lost an 8 month old boy on 28 Oct 1892, but the death certificate index neglects to list his name and shows him buried at St. Mary's Cemetery. Given the missing name, can only wonder if the burial location is accurate.

  15. I apparently live in a house that use to be connected to the stone mason that built tombstones for LaFayette. I have an old unfinished tombstone in my backyard. Just learned yesterday of the history of capitolo park.

  16. I have been looking for years for the actual "resting" place of my great-great grandfather, Joseph M. Johnston, who was buried in Lafayette in 1871. He was a veteran of the Union Army, 91st Pa Volunteer Infantry, Company D and fought for the Union for four years, most memorably on Little Round
    top at Gettysburg. I wonder where his remains are. I had been told in the past to "look in Neshaminy creek." Your post gives me more information. Thank you.

  17. I'm still researching stuff and trying to figure this all out..just amazes me..yes where are all the beautiful stones and markers?